myguido
Stout friar in a belted black habit, standing against a blue sky, right hand raised and a book in his left, a golden sun beside his head
Piero della Francesca, San Nicola da Tolentino · Photo: Piero della Francesca, Public domain

Stop 6 of 8Must-see

Piero della Francesca's Saint Nicholas

Where to stand

In the Salone Dorato, in front of the tall, narrow panel of a friar in a black habit against the sky

One piece of a dismantled masterpiece. Piero della Francesca painted this saint for a great in his hometown, Sansepolcro. The altarpiece was broken up, and today it is split between Milan, London, Lisbon, New York and Washington.

Spot the detail

The friar's belt: see how it strains across his belly

The full story

This friar has seven companions scattered across Europe and America, and for centuries he did not see them.

Start with the shape of the panel: tall, narrow, with a standing figure that fills it completely. It is the format of someone who stood beside someone else. And indeed the San Nicola da Tolentino, Saint Nicholas of Tolentino, was one compartment of a .

It was painted by Piero della Francesca, one of the great masters of the fifteenth century, for the high altar of the Augustinian church in Sansepolcro, his hometown. He began in 1454 and worked on it for fifteen years. Piero was not a man to be rushed.

An altarpiece in pieces

Probably as early as the sixteenth century, the altarpiece was taken apart and the pieces went their separate ways. Today Saint Augustine is in Lisbon, the archangel Michael in London, Saint John the Evangelist in New York, Saint Apollonia in Washington. The central panel is lost. The Saint Nicholas entered the collection of Gian Giacomo Poldi Pezzoli, the collector count who lived in this house.

In 2024 the seemingly impossible happened. It had been tried three times before, without ever securing all the loans. This time the eight surviving panels came back side by side, right here, for three months.

That had not happened since the altarpiece was dismantled. Then each one left again for its own city.

A saint with an invented face

Now look at him. Nicholas of Tolentino was a thirteenth-century friar, proclaimed a saint only in 1446. For the Augustinians who had ordered the altarpiece he was the order's latest glory, almost breaking news.

Piero had no face to copy, so he invents one. He gives him a serious face, the face of a real person, and a solid body planted in front of a marble parapet.

Then find the halo. It was usually a flat gold circle behind the head. Piero treats it as a real object: a metal disk that tilts with the head and obeys perspective. He even wrote a treatise on those rules. Look for the star too: according to legend, it marked the place where the saint was to be buried.

His whole way of painting is right here. The sacred is present, but it has weight and measure, like anything else in the world.

About this stop

Anecdote

Piero della Francesca: eight panels reunited

In the Museo Poldi Pezzoli's Salone Dorato hangs a Saint Nicholas of Tolentino by Piero della Francesca, a fifteenth-century master. It was one panel of a , taken apart centuries ago. Putting it back together was a dream: the museum tried in 1996, then New York's Frick Collection in 2013 and the Hermitage in 2018, but the loans never all came through. In the spring of 2024 the museum pulled it off. The eight surviving panels, seven of them arriving from New York, London, Lisbon and Washington, were shown together for three months. Only the central panel and most of the small scenes at the base, all lost, were missing.

Legend

Saint Nicholas's star

In the Salone Dorato, the Golden Room of the Museo Poldi Pezzoli, hangs a Saint Nicholas of Tolentino by Piero della Francesca, a fifteenth-century master: a friar in a black habit against the sky. Near him shines a star. It is not an ornament. According to legend, a star marked the place where Nicholas was to be buried. Piero takes up the story, but puts the star where he pleases: its position, the museum explains, is his own free choice, like the saint's face, which is invented. Nicholas had been canonized only a few years earlier, and the painter could afford to take a few liberties.

Next stop

Still in the Salone Dorato, look for Botticelli's small Madonna reading beside a window

7 Botticelli's Madonna del Libro