Stop 7 of 7Must-see
Manzoni, Merda d'artista
Where to stand
Among the rooms of the 1950s and 1960s, in front of Piero Manzoni's small tin can
A thirty-gram can called Artist's Shit, dated 1961 and sold for its weight in gold. Inside, the label says, is just what you think. It is the cheekiest work in the museum and one of the century's most serious questions: who decides what art is worth?
Spot the detail
Read the label: how many languages is it in, and what number is on the can?
The full story
It is the size of a can of meat, and it has made more noise than many a monumental work. Step closer and read the label.
It says: Merda d'artista, Artist's Shit. Net contents thirty grams. Freshly preserved. Produced and canned in May 1961.
The artist is Piero Manzoni, one of the group behind the magazine Azimuth. He prepared ninety cans, numbered and signed. Then he set their value: each can, its weight in gold. Thirty grams of shit against thirty grams of pure gold, at the day's rate.
The reasoning behind the joke
A joke? That too. In those same years Manzoni was selling balloons he had inflated himself, under the title Fiato d'artista, Artist's Breath.
But there is a precise line of reasoning behind it, and he wrote it down himself in a letter to the artist Ben Vautier. If collectors want something intimate, something truly personal, there is the artist's shit: that really is his.
Think about how the market works. A signed painting is worth more than the same painting unsigned. So what you pay for is the name, the trace of the person, almost as if it were a relic. Manzoni follows the logic to the end and presents the bill.
What is inside the can
The stroke of genius is that you cannot check. To find out what is inside you have to open the can, and opening it means destroying the work. So the rumors have multiplied.
Agostino Bonalumi, an artist and a friend of Manzoni's, stated that there is nothing inside but plaster. Another friend, the actor Cochi Ponzoni, has said that it is jam, and that the artist's sister always said so. A French artist, Bernard Bazile, actually opened one: he found a second container inside, and stopped there.
In the end the answer changes nothing. If it is shit, someone paid gold for shit. If it is plaster, they paid gold for a lie. The work succeeds either way.
From Parliament to the auctions
And it has succeeded all too well. Ten years later, a Manzoni exhibition in Rome ended up in Parliament, with a formal question from an outraged deputy. Today the cans sit in the Tate in London, the Centre Pompidou in Paris, MoMA in New York.
In 2016, in Milan, one sold at auction for a six-figure sum: far more than its weight in gold. The market Manzoni was mocking took him seriously. Which is to say, it proved him right.
You may find it brilliant or unbearable. But just try leaving the museum without having argued about it with someone.
About this stop
Anecdote
The can of Merda d'artista that leaked
On display at Milan's Museo del Novecento is a small tin of Merda d'artista, Artist's Shit: the artist Piero Manzoni packaged ninety of them in 1961. Nobody knows what they contain, because opening one means destroying the work. But at least one has shown signs of life. In 1994 one was exhibited in a museum in Randers, Denmark. The collector John Hunov later accused the museum of having made it leak by keeping it too warm. The dispute ended with compensation. If the leak really happened, it is tempting to think there is more inside than plaster, which is what Agostino Bonalumi, an artist and a friend of Manzoni's, maintained.
It is a provocation with an argument. Manzoni explained it in a 1961 letter to the artist Ben Vautier: if collectors are after something intimate and personal from the artist, nothing is more so than his shit. The work mocks the cult of the signature, by which an object is valuable because someone famous touched it, like a relic. The painter Enrico Baj called it an act of defiance and mockery aimed at the art world, artists, and critics. That the same world then bought it and put it in a display case is part of the work.